News

Return to Office Is Not About Control. It’s About Trust.

Over the last few years, debates over remote work have centered on flexibility, productivity, and cost savings. But beneath all the spreadsheets, Zoom calls, and badge-swipe arguments lies something more foundational: trust.

The most overlooked reason companies ask employees to return to the office isn’t because they crave control or hate pajamas. It is because building high-performing, high-trust teams is incredibly hard to do through a screen. Moreover, the rewards of a high-trust corporate environment are often worth the sacrifice.

Remote Work Isn’t the Problem. Trust Is.

Plenty of companies have made remote work operational. Projects still ship, and revenue still flows. But quiet attrition, most often felt in the erosion of trust, accountability, and connection, has become harder to ignore.

According to Gallup, only 2 in 10 employees strongly agree that their organization’s leadership communicates effectively. Remote environments amplify this weakness. Without hallway chats or face-to-face tension defusers, miscommunications linger longer, performance issues fester, and collaboration weakens.

What’s really at stake with return-to-office mandates isn’t productivity. It’s cohesion. Trust is built on repetition, proximity, and vulnerability, which don’t translate well over Slack.

High-Trust Teams Share Three Qualities

Patrick Lencioni’s research in The Five Dysfunctions of a Team highlights that trust is the bedrock of successful teamwork. But in practical terms, what does a high-trust team look like?

1. Psychological Safety: People can admit mistakes, ask for help, or challenge ideas without fear of judgment.

2. Shared Goals and Norms: Everyone rows in the same direction, with mutual clarity about what “done well” looks like.

3. Cultural Consistency: The informal cues—the jokes, the rituals, the body language—create a shared sense of identity.

Remote work often degrades these three elements. Without physical proximity, safety becomes politeness, goals get muddled, and culture becomes a Google Doc.

The Office Is a Trust Accelerator

When designed intentionally, the office becomes a “trust accelerator.” It’s not about micromanagement, it’s about building the invisible tissue that holds teams together. Here’s why being physically present still matters:

• Spontaneity builds trust: Research shows unplanned interactions spark idea-sharing and deepen relationships. These are hard to manufacture digitally.

• Non-verbal communication is key: Over 70% of communication is non-verbal. In-person meetings allow team members to calibrate tone, intent, and nuance in ways that email or video can’t.

• Observational learning matters: Junior team members learn norms, skills, and decision-making not just by being told what to do, but by seeing how others do it.

Remote-Only Trust Is a Privilege of Long-Standing Teams

There’s a difference between maintaining trust and building it.

Remote work can sustain trust within long-established teams that have built strong relationships. But building trust from scratch, onboarding new hires, forming new teams, and navigating conflict is exponentially harder without in-person interaction.

In fact, a study from Microsoft found that remote work led to more siloed collaboration and weakened the strength of cross-functional ties over time. In other words, remote work encourages people to stay in their lane. That might help efficiency in the short term, but it undercuts innovation, mentorship, and organizational loyalty.

What Return to Office Should Be About

If leaders frame return-to-office as a control play, exemplified by the idea that executives “want to see people working,” they’ll lose the culture war. But if they position it as a strategic investment in trust, it becomes a value proposition.

Effective return-to-office strategies should not be focused on mandating time at a desk. They’re about creating intentional moments that restore connection, reinforce culture, and rebuild trust.

That looks like:

• Cross-team collaboration sessions

• Strategic planning meetings in person

• Informal social rituals (lunches, standups, walk-and-talks)

• Mentorship pairings that meet face-to-face weekly

The goal isn’t to recreate 2019. It’s to build an environment where trust isn’t assumed, but actively earned.

Leaders Must Go First

Building trust is a leadership function. If executives aren’t visible, aren’t available, or aren’t modeling vulnerability, no mandate will work.

As Simon Sinek said, “A team is not a group of people who work together. A team is a group of people who trust each other.”

In the return-to-office era, leaders must be physically and emotionally present. That means:

• Walking the floor

• Asking questions and listening deeply

• Being open about mistakes or uncertainties

• Investing in face time, not just face time policies

Hybrid Can Work—But Only with Intent

Hybrid work has become the compromise of choice. But it won’t magically rebuild trust unless it’s intentional.

That means aligning when teams come in and why. It also means designing office space that supports collaboration, not rows of empty desks. The office shouldn’t feel like punishment; it should feel like value.

Organizations like Atlassian and Salesforce have invested in “team days,” where cross-functional groups come together weekly or bi-weekly to brainstorm, solve, and connect. Others, like Shopify, have reimagined their real estate footprint to prioritize collaboration hubs over individual desks.

Hybrid only works when the in-office moments are worth it.

Trust Low? Productivity Will Follow.

Leaders obsessed with productivity should care more about trust than timecards. Low-trust teams:

• Avoid conflict

• Withhold feedback

• Hoard information

• Burn out faster

• Leave more often

In contrast, high-trust teams are more resilient, creative, and committed, even in volatile markets.

The ROI of trust is real. PwC’s research shows that companies with high-trust cultures outperform their peers in profitability, innovation, and retention. But trust is not built in isolation; it’s built together.

The Bottom Line

Return to office isn’t about reversing remote work. It’s about returning to relationships.

In a world increasingly mediated by screens, the companies that succeed will be the ones that understand this simple truth: trust scales best face to face.

That doesn’t necessarily mean five days a week or rigid 5 day a week mandates. But it means asking: How do we create the kind of culture where people trust each other enough to speak up, collaborate boldly, and stay for the long term?

That’s not a facilities issue. That’s a leadership issue.

And the office used right isn’t a cost center. It’s your most powerful trust-building tool.

Watch Our Full Podcast On Building High-Trust Teams & Return To Work